Skip to content
Left
Continue shopping
Your Order
You have no items in your cart
Instagram
NYC's #1 Neighborhood Pet Store Since 1991
Shop by Pet
Dog
All Dog Food
Cooked Dog Food
Dry Dog Food
Freeze-Dried Dog Food
Frozen Dog Food
Raw Dog Food
Refrigerated Dog Food
Wet Dog Food
Dog Food Toppers
Dog Treats
Dog Toys
Dog Healthcare
Dog Supplies & Accessories
Cat
All Cat Food
Cooked Cat Food
Dry Cat Food
Freeze-Dried Cat Food
Frozen Cat Food
Raw Cat Food
Refrigerated Cat Food
Wet Cat Food
Cat Food Toppers
Cat Treats
Cat Toys
Cat Healthcare
Cat Supplies & Accessories
Cat Litter
Other Animals
Bird Food & Supplies
Fish Food & Supplies
Reptile/Amphibian Food & Supplies
Small Animal Food & Supplies
Shop by Brand
Brands A-E
Adams
Answers
Benebone
Best Pet
Blue Buffalo
Bocce's Bakery
Bubu
The Butcher's Pup
Carna4
Cat-Man-Doo
Dr Marty
Earth Animal
Brands F-M
FabDog
FreshPet
Fromm
Fussie Cat
Hill's
Icelandic
Koha
Kong
McLovin's
MultiPet
Brands N-R
Open Farm
Orijen
Outward Hound
Oxbow
P.L.A.Y.
Portland Pet
Primal
Prime100
A Pup Above
Raw Dynamic
RAWZ
Rockster
Royal Canin
Brands S-Z
SmallBatch
Snug Arooz
SPOT
Starmark
Stella & Chewy's
Tetra
Wellness
Weruva
NYC Store Locations
W72nd Street (Broadway Riverside)
W72nd Street (Amsterdam/B'way/Columbus)
Lenox Hill / Upper East Side
W57th Street / Columbus Circle
Manhattan Valley / Columbia University
Central Park West / Upper West Side
About Us
Contact Us
Best selling products
Home
/
Best selling products
Filter
Sort by:
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Submit
Filter
Price
$
$
Brand
A Pup Above
4
Adams
2
Answers
6
Applaws
4
Ark Naturals
10
Arm & Hammer
5
Benebone
2
Best Pet
14
Blue Buffalo
10
Bocce's Bakery
4
Bubu Brands
3
Butcher's Pup
6
Carefresh
2
Carna4
7
Cat Dancer
1
Cat-Man-Doo
2
Chuckit!
1
Coastal
14
Conair
1
Diggin' Your Dog
1
Dr Elsey's
2
Dr Marty
4
Earth Animal
8
Earth Rated
4
Earthbath
2
Ever Clean
2
Fabdog
2
Feline Natural
9
Feline Pine
1
Flexi
1
Four Paws
3
Fresh News
1
Fresh Step
5
FreshPet
7
Fromm
32
Fussie Cat
7
Greenies
6
Greenline
2
Grizzly
1
Higgins
7
Hill's
4
Icelandic
1
Inaba
14
Instinct
7
Kaytee
2
Kitty Sift
1
Koha
6
Kong
4
Lotus
1
McLovin's
1
Merrick
6
Messy Cats
2
Mika & Sammy's
4
Multipet
5
Naturally Fresh
2
Natures Miracle
2
Nummy Tum Tum
2
Open Farm
30
Orijen
22
Outward Hound
3
Oxbow
9
Petmate
1
PetSafe
5
Pioneer Pet
1
PLAY
1
Portland Pet
7
Prevue
1
Primal
42
Prime100
5
Pure & Natural Pet
1
Purina
2
Raw Dynamic
22
Rawz
21
Rockster
6
Royal Canin
1
Sam's Yams
1
Scoop Away
1
Sherpa
2
Small Batch
28
SmartCat
1
SnugArooz
2
SPOT
3
Starmark
2
Stella & Chewy's
37
Stella & Chewys
1
Sunseed
9
Swheat Scoop
2
Temptations
6
Tetra
7
Tidy Cats
5
Tilted Barn
3
Under The Weather
4
Van Ness
2
Virbac
4
Wellness
31
Weruva
34
World's Best
4
Yeowww! Catnip
3
Ziwi Peak
4
Zymox
3
Submit
Best Pet Pig Ear
$3
49
Add to cart
Best Pet Single Bladder Stick
$3
99
Add to cart
Best Pet Spiral Bully Stick
$9
99
Unavailable
Best Pet Supplies Cardboard Catify Cat Scratcher
$12
99
Add to cart
Best Pet Supplies Mesh Waste Bag Dispenser - Baby Blue
$12
99
Add to cart
Best Pet Supplies Mesh Waste Bag Dispenser - Black
$12
99
Add to cart
Best Pet Supplies Mesh Waste Bag Dispenser - Pink
$12
99
Add to cart
Best Pet Supplies Waste Bags - 10 15 Count Rolls (150 Bags) Assorted Colors
$14
99
Add to cart
Best Pet Supplies Waste Bags - 10 15 Count Rolls (150 Bags) Black with White Paws
$14
99
Add to cart
Best Pet Supplies Waste Bags - 10 15 Count Rolls (150 Bags) Blue with White Bones & Paws
$14
99
Add to cart
Best Pet Tendon Stick
$9
99
Add to cart
Blue Buffalo Dry Dog Food Life Protection Formula Adult Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe
$24
99
Add to cart
Blue Buffalo Dry Dog Food Life Protection Formula Adult Healthy Weight Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe
$24
99
Add to cart
Blue Buffalo Dry Dog Food Life Protection Formula Adult Small Breed Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe
$28
99
Add to cart
Blue Buffalo Dry Dog Food Life Protection Formula Puppy Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe
$24
99
Add to cart
Blue Buffalo Dry Dog Food Wilderness Adult Chicken
$29
99
Add to cart
Blue Buffalo Dry Dog Food Wilderness Adult Salmon
$34
99
Add to cart
Blue Homestyle Chicken Dinner with Garden Vegetables for Dogs
$4
79
Add to cart
Blue Homestyle Recipe Beef Dinner with Garden Vegetables For Dogs
$4
79
Add to cart
Blue Homestyle Recipe Chicken Dinner With Garden Vegetables Food for Puppies
$4
79
Add to cart
Blue Homestyle Recipe Senior Chicken Dinner With Garden Vegetables Food for Dogs
$4
79
Add to cart
Bocce's Dog Treat Soft & Chewy Chicken Recipe
$12
99
Add to cart
Bocce's Dog Treat Soft & Chewy Duck Recipe
$12
99
Add to cart
Bocce's Dog Treat Soft & Chewy Peanut Butter & Banana Recipe
$12
99
Add to cart
Bocce's Dog Treat Training Bites Quack, Quack, Quack
$12
99
Add to cart
Bubu Tiny Bones Peanut Butter and Blueberry
$16
99
Unavailable
Bubu Tiny Bones Pumpkin and Cranberry
$16
99
Add to cart
Bubu Whole Muscle Chicken Jerky
$20
99
Add to cart
Carefresh Small Pet Bedding Confetti
$12
99
Add to cart
Carefresh Small Pet Bedding Natural
From
$9
99
Show options
Carna4 Chicken Formula for Cats
$28
99
Add to cart
Carna4 Dry Dog Food Chicken Formula
From
$29
99
Show options
Carna4 Dry Dog Food Duck Formula
From
$34
99
Show options
Carna4 Dry Dog Food Easy-Chew Fish Formula
From
$26
99
Show options
Carna4 Dry Dog Food Easy-Chew Lamb Formula
From
$28
99
Show options
Carna4 Dry Dog Food Easy-Chew Venison Formula
From
$28
99
Show options
654 results
Left
1
2
3
4
…
19
Right